Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter

The main pros of the game

• Engaging Storyline: Many s appreciated the intriguing plot and the build-up of the story, with some mentioning it as a good introduction to the Sherlock Holmes series.
• Interesting Cases: Players found the cases to be interesting and enjoyed the investigative elements, which included finding clues and solving puzzles.
• Gameplay Options: The option to skip certain puzzles and interactions was viewed positively by some s, making the game more accessible.
• Visuals and Graphics: Some players noted that the graphics showed progress over the years and were satisfactory for the game's context.
• Overall Enjoyment: A number of s expressed enjoyment in playing as Sherlock Holmes, highlighting the immersive experience.

The main cons of the game

• Disappointment for Fans: Many long-time fans of Sherlock Holmes expressed disappointment, feeling that the game deviated significantly from the spirit of the original stories.
• Gameplay Mechanics: s criticized the fighting mechanics as being poorly executed and felt that the game sometimes resembled a platformer rather than a traditional adventure game.
• Camera Control Issues: Terrible camera movement was frequently mentioned as a significant problem, affecting the overall gameplay experience.
• Character Design Changes: Players were unhappy with the redesign of Sherlock and John, expressing confusion and dislike for their new appearances.
• Storytelling and Pacing: Some reviews pointed out that the story had too much drama and lacked rational thinking, which detracted from the detective experience.

The features or elements that are missing from the game according to s

• Open World Exploration: Players missed the open-world aspect present in previous titles, feeling that the game was more linear.
• More Complex Puzzles: Several s expressed a desire for more challenging puzzles, noting that many were too easy or felt like "try and error."
• Impactful Choices: While the game allows for dialogue choices, s noted that these choices did not significantly affect the outcome of the story, which could have enhanced the experience.
• Better Combat Mechanics: There was a call for improved combat systems or a reduction in combat elements altogether, as many found them cumbersome and unnecessary.
• Less Action Focus: Some players felt that the game included too much action and not enough focus on the investigative elements that define the Sherlock Holmes franchise.

Summary

• Overall, while "Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter" has its merits, particularly in storytelling and engaging gameplay, it has also faced criticism from fans and players alike, especially regarding its departure from traditional elements of the series.

Summary generated on: November 25, 2024